A New Take on the Iconic Girl Reading a Letter by Vermeer
The recently restored Girl Reading a Letter at an Open Window by Johannes Vermeer (1632-1675) is often said to be that of a young woman reading a...
Tom Anderson 26 September 2024
min Read
18 September 2024Paul Delaroche’s Execution of Lady Jane Grey is a mesmerizing piece that captures the essence and tragedy of one of England’s most ill-fated queens, who was beheaded at the Tower of London at just 17. The painting was rediscovered in 1973, adding to his oeuvre of historical paintings and immortalizing the young queen as a legend. Known for his evocative and technically sophisticated artworks, Delaroche brings to life the brief yet impactful reign of Lady Jane Grey through a painting that resonates with historical and emotional depth.
Lady Jane Grey, born on October 1537, was the great-granddaughter of the English King Henry VII and a cousin to Queen Elizabeth I, and so had a tenuous claim to the throne. In 1553, Jane was forced to marry Lord Guildford Dudley, the son of a prominent and wealthy nobleman. Although legally questionable, her claim to the English throne placed her at the center of a fierce political struggle catalyzed by Queen Mary Tudor, or as she is popularly known as, ‘Bloody Mary.’
Jane’s brief nine-day reign as the Queen of England in July 1553 marked a turbulent period in English history, characterized by death, war, religious turmoil, and power struggles following the death of King Edward VI, the first son of King Henry VIII and Jane Seymour.
Jane was a Protestant, and her ascension was supported by those who sought to maintain Protestant reforms against the Catholic Queen Mary I, who succeeded her. The political machinations against her were swift and decisive, leading to her imprisonment and eventual execution in February 1554. Her tragic fate and the brief nature of her rule have made her a poignant symbol of innocence lost amid political strife.
Delaroche’s painting of Lady Jane Grey is a masterclass in portraiture, distinguished by its meticulous attention to detail and evocative use of color and light. He captures the harrowing final moments of the teenage queen, who, blindfolded, famously queries,
What should I do? Where is the block?
As Sir John Brydges, the Lieutenant of the Tower, leads her toward her grim fate, Lady Grey’s outer garments are already discarded, resting in the lap of a fainted lady-in-waiting. Another attendant, standing behind Jane, faces the wall in distress, unable to bear the sight. To the side, the executioner waits in silence. By employing a confined, stage-like setting, dramatic lighting, and lifelike figures, Delaroche enhances the dramatic tension of this tragic scene, urging viewers to confront the emotional intensity of Lady Jane’s imminent demise.
The artist employs a classical approach to composition, with Jane positioned centrally against a muted background that highlights her figure. Chiaroscuro—a technique involving solid contrasts between light and dark—enhances the three-dimensionality of her form and creates an emotional and highly charged atmosphere.
Delaroche’s technique in rendering Jane’s attire is particularly noteworthy. The texture of her silk gown, meticulously detailed with delicate brushstrokes, suggests both opulence and restraint. The rich fabrics and intricate embroidery are rendered with a realism that speaks to the artist’s skill and attention to historical accuracy.
Beyond its formal qualities, the painting has a deep emotional resonance. The Execution of Lady Jane Grey captures the tension between the queen’s youthful innocence and the harsh reality of her circumstances. The soft tilt of her head and the slight parting of her lips, often interpreted as sad or contemplative, reflects the inner turmoil, isolation, and resignation she must have felt during her imprisonment. The lack of elaborate background details contrasts with the richly adorned attire, suggesting the disparity between her dignity and her precarious political position.
Paul Delaroche’s portrait of Lady Jane Grey is more than a historical representation; it is a profound commentary on the intersection of power, innocence, and tragedy. Through his masterful technique and composition, Delaroche captures Lady Jane Grey’s almost mythological status and conveys the emotional and psychological weight of her brief and troubled reign.
Lady Jane Grey’s story captured the people’s imaginations, viewing her tragedy as akin to Romeo and Juliet. Film as far back as the silent screen has been telling her story. In recent portrayals, she is often shown as a fierce and self-assured young woman, breaking away from the traditional image of her as merely a tragic figure. These modern takes on her story highlight her determination, making her more than just a pawn in political games. Instead, she comes across as a savvy and confident character, taking charge of her fate in a tumultuous time. By showcasing Lady Jane Grey as a proactive and bold individual, these recent depictions breathe new life into her narrative and make her an even more compelling figure on screen.
Lady Jane Grey Reference Guide, Tamise, 2024. Accessed: 26 Aug. 2024.
The Execution of Lady Jane Grey, National Gallery Online Collection. Accessed: 26 Aug. 2024.
Matilda Jones, Write on Art: ‘The Execution of Lady Jane Grey’ by Paul Delaroche, ART UK, 2023. Accessed: 26 Aug. 2024.
DailyArt Magazine needs your support. Every contribution, however big or small, is very valuable for our future. Thanks to it, we will be able to sustain and grow the Magazine. Thank you for your help!